Meet the humans of Hebron's Pie Festival

Photo by Ella Diehl

Photo by Ella Diehl

On Saturday, Sept. 13, 2025, hundreds of people lined up on the sidewalk of Route 40 — adults lounged in lawn chairs and kids kicked back in their wagons — waiting for the Hebron Pie Festival parade to begin a pie-filled day of activities.

The parade began at 11, and was followed by pie eating contests, live music, baking contests and the crowning of pie royalty.

The Reporting Project asked people attending the fourth annual festival what the event means to them, and how it supported Hebron's community.

This is a feature of a continuing series depicting the lives of the people of Licking County.

Answers have been edited for clarity.

Hebron Mayor Valerie Mockus. Photo by Ella Diehl

Hebron Mayor Valerie Mockus. Photo by Ella Diehl

Hebron Mayor Valerie Mockus

“Most people love pie. So that's easy. But really, what this is about is building community and reminding each other why we live here, or why we grow here. We still live here. The whole point is to come together and create community.” 

“In Hebron, we value hard work. We value people taking care of their neighbors. We all know our neighbors, and if somebody has a problem, they will literally call you at any time and knock on your door. And I think people who value that love living in small towns, because the whole point is to be close and connected, but not be overwhelmed.”

“Breaking bread is a very human tradition, right? And so for us to do it around a food item, and people can get whatever kind they like and sit down and listen to someone singing with their friends and their family and enjoy this gorgeous weather…I mean, that's why we have green space, using that to bring people together.”

Pie festival attendees danced to a variety of live music acts throughout the day. Photo by Ella Diehl

Pie festival attendees danced to a variety of live music acts throughout the day. Photo by Ella Diehl

The father-son duo Brandon and Eli Ours returned to the Hebron Pie Festival this year to maintain their winning streak. In 2024, Brandon won the adult pie eating contest, while Eli won the kids pie eating contest. This year, they both won again.

Brandon: “Eating is about the only thing that I'm good at. I don't really have a strategy. I just do what I do, I guess.”

Eli :  “I'm pretty competitive, so I like to feel like I won something.”

Photo by Ella Diehl

Photo by Ella Diehl

Photo by Brie Coleman

Photo by Brie Coleman

Photo by Brie Coleman

Photo by Brie Coleman

Photo by Brie Coleman

Photo by Brie Coleman

Photo by Ella Diehl

Photo by Ella Diehl

Photo by Brie Coleman

Photo by Brie Coleman

Beth Cochran and Leah Scobee enjoy the pie while selling Cochran's artwork at the festival. Photo by Brie Coleman

Beth Cochran and Leah Scobee enjoy the pie while selling Cochran's artwork at the festival. Photo by Brie Coleman

Ava Bowman, a Hebron resident and member of The Shining Stars, performed during the pie festival alongside Leighton Augenstein. Bowman attends Lakewood Middle School.

“Hebron is a very small and kind community I’d say, we are all very helpful to each other.”

Leighton Augenstein (left) and Ava Bowman (right). Photo by Ella Diehl

Leighton Augenstein (left) and Ava Bowman (right). Photo by Ella Diehl

Photo by Brie Coleman

Photo by Brie Coleman

Tim and Joyce Blackstone

The Blackstones originally lived in Granville and owned a business called The Blackstone Deli. Students from Denison used to love grabbing sandwiches there after classes. Now, they have started involving themselves more with the Hebron community as their grandson attends Lakewood High School.

This is the couple’s first time at the Pie Festival. Joyce even entered a Dutch apple pie into the pie contest. “I came for the fun and because I love to bake,” Joyce said. “I think [the festival] is a good thing, bringing a lot of people here to Hebron.” 

Photo by Delaney Brown

Photo by Delaney Brown

Jack Neely

Cherry pie is his favorite, but for his first time at the pie festival, Jack Neely entered an apple pie. “Community is being involved with one another and helping other people when you can.” 

Photo by Ella Diehl

Photo by Ella Diehl

Hebron Village Council President Randy Wolf (left) and Village Water Superintendent Jason Figgins (right) attend the Hebron Pie Festival. Photo by Ella Diehl

Hebron Village Council President Randy Wolf (left) and Village Water Superintendent Jason Figgins (right) attend the Hebron Pie Festival. Photo by Ella Diehl

Randy Wolf and Jason Figgins

Randy: “It makes you think about when you're growing up and you had Thanksgiving dinner and you had apple pie. It's a tight-knit community. Everybody seems to know everybody and everybody else's business…. Everybody looks out for everybody and helps. If there's something that needs done, everybody will pitch in and help.”

Jason: “Pie just makes people happy. ... I started working for the town back in the '90s, and coming again from Zanesville, this town welcomed me with open arms. So this place is like my second home.”

Mike Prince (left), Hebron Income Tax Administrator Mindy Kester (center) and Hebron Utility Billing Coordinator Brigette Rose (right). Photo by Ella Diehl

Mike Prince (left), Hebron Income Tax Administrator Mindy Kester (center) and Hebron Utility Billing Coordinator Brigette Rose (right). Photo by Ella Diehl

Mike Prince, Mindy Kester and Brigette Rose

Kester works for the village of Hebron and has lived there her entire life. Last year she entered the pie contest and won third place. She feels the Pie Festival “is about [people] coming together and having a good time.” The pie contest requires participants to submit two pies each: one for the judges and one to be auctioned off. The proceeds go to the Hebron Historical Society to help fund the festival.

Brigette:“Community is very important, it’s an extension of your family. It’s needed for being balanced and for good well-being. The pie festival is fun. A lot of people smile when they eat pie, so it’s fun.”

Photo by Ella Diehl

Photo by Ella Diehl

Brittany Misner, Hebron's economic and community development director

“It’s been a big day for our community, we’ve been really focused on opportunities to bring everyone together and I don’t think there is anything we’ve done that quite accomplishes what today accomplishes. Not only are we bringing people of all ages together, we have our youth sports, we have our nonprofits, we have so many young people here being recognized. It’s just an exciting day for our community.”

“I would absolutely say this is what community looks like in Hebron. It’s celebrating our youth, it’s being proud to be from Hebron and America and celebrating the talents of all kinds of different people.”

“I definitely can’t take credit for the selection of pie, but I was just saying to my coworker earlier that I’m so glad that pie is our thing. There is nothing more American than a good slice of pie. The funny story, how it all came to be, is our previous mayor wanted to host something like this and was pitching it to our current mayor and said 'what do you think is something everybody loves?' And she’s like 'potatoes!' And they are like 'no, pie.' I think pie was the right choice. There is a little bit of something for everyone.”

Photo by Ella Diehl

Photo by Ella Diehl

Brent Jones, from Newark, attended the pie festival for the first time this year. Photo by Brie Coleman

Brent Jones, from Newark, attended the pie festival for the first time this year. Photo by Brie Coleman

Brent Jones

This is Jone’s first time at the Pie Festival, and he attended to support his daughter who performed in the Lakewood High School band. When it comes to describing the Pie Festival, Jones said, “[It’s a] simple event that brings people together to smile, talk and laugh. It seems to be a good recipe for a community.” 

Photo by Ella Diehl

Photo by Ella Diehl

Clark Corum

Clark Corum was dressed as the pie festival mascot, “Home Slice.” He is a student at Lakewood High school and says he finds community in Hebron. “Community is a group of people that you can fall on in hard times,” Corum said.

Photo by Ella Diehl

Photo by Ella Diehl

Stephanie and Scott Bambenek

Stephanie Bambenek: “For me it means community and history and comradery with everybody and delicious pie, of course. You can’t forget about the pie. The competition, the spark of local people making pies, not knowing who made them. ... I just think that that’s really fun. It sparks really good competition. I’m hoping to win one. I put a really good bid in so finger’s crossed.”

Photo by Brie Coleman

Photo by Brie Coleman

After the kids and adult pie eating contest concluded, mayors from Hebron and nearby towns joined together to participate in the mayoral pie eating contest. Hebron Mayor Valerie Mockus, Pleasantville Mayor Jason Henderson, Thurston Mayor Gina Matos and Millersport Mayor Gary Matheny competed for the gold by finishing their fry pie first.

In a tight finish, Mockus completed her fry pie first. Matheny was a close second, with just a few crumbs left.

Photo by Ella Diehl

Photo by Ella Diehl

Delaney Brown, Brie Coleman, Ella Diehl, Shaye Phillips and Tyler Thompson write for TheReportingProject.org, the nonprofit news organization of Denison University’s Journalism program, which is supported by generous donations from readers. Sign up for The Reporting Project newsletter here.